Plato's dialogues are full of Socrates. The question is whether he wrote any dialogues during Socrates' life-time, or whether he began to write dialogues only after the death of Socrates. On this question the internet 'informs' his readers quite definitely: Plato began to write his dialogues after Socrates' death.
In Platonic Chronology and Writings the first period of Plato's writings begins in 399, the date of Socrates' death. The section on Meno is introduced with the words 'Meno is a Socratic dialogue written by Plato around 385 BC., but set at an earlier date around 402 BC.'
This is wrong; Plato must have written the Meno before Socrates died.
There are few things or events, if any, that can be proved with as much certainty, as the fact that the Meno was written before Socrates died.
In the Meno there is a discussion between Socrates and Anytus - the man who will become Socrates' accuser at the trial - at which Socrates subjects Anytus, the leading politician of those days, to painful irony:
Meno reiterates the main subject of the discussion by asking Socrates: 'Do you think there are no teachers of virtue?' In his reply Socrates introduces Anytus into the discussion. 'But look, Meno: here, at the very moment when he was wanted, we have Anytus sitting down beside us, to take his share in our quest. And we may well ask his assistance; for Anytus is, firstly, the son of a wise and wealthy father, Anthemion, who became rich by his own skill and industry; and further, he gave his son a good upbringing and education, as the Athenian people think, for they chose him for the highest offices.'
This pained; some three years later, at the trial, 'Anytus and his associates' (hoi amphi Anyton, Plato Apology 17b3) stand behind Meletus' accusation of Socrates.
In the Apology Socrates points to 'Anytus and his associates' (tous amphi Anyton) as his present accusers (18a-b). If Plato wrote the Meno after the death of Socrates, how could he possibly end it with the following words of Socrates: 'It is time now for me to go my way, but do you persuade our friend Anytus of that whereof you are now yourself persuaded, so as to put him in a gentler mood; for if you can persuade him, you will do a good turn to the people of Athens also'?
May I hope that now, in the reign of Donald Trump, the truth about the dating of the Meno will be put on the internet?
No comments:
Post a Comment